There has been quite a lot of debate in my house as to whether this is sung 'live' or not! I'm inclined to think it is....there are a couple of (minor!) wobbles which, if it was recorded in a studio, there wouldn't be any reason for. And I would expect the sound reprodudtion to be better. Having forced other members of my family to watch this repeatedly whilst listening on headphones, they are now inclined to agree.....although that could just be to shut me up!
I am absolutely not sure if it is live or not and may just remain unsure forever, I guess this means i am going to have to keep watching and re-watching forever too? sigh. it's a tough job but someone has to do it.
I think it is live because he has a little catch of his breath towards the end just before he turns round and does the big finish. It is when he says "umberellas"!
-- Edited by Pearl24 on Sunday 17th of March 2013 09:50:47 AM