Welcome to DMF!
To join the discussion & for more content, log in or register here!


Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
 

Topic: Being Human Series 5 Episode 1 - 'The Trinity' | Sunday 3 February 10pm BBC Three

Post Info
DMF
Status: Offline
Posts: 5400
Date:
Being Human Series 5 Episode 1 - 'The Trinity' | Sunday 3 February 10pm BBC Three
Permalink  
 

 

The first episode of Being Human 5 has been officially named 'The Trinity'.

Below is the official synopsis and broadcast info (with lovely new pic!) from the BBC Three Being Human Website

click on the link for full info and credits >> http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b01qm2zc

 

The Trinity

 


Image for The Trinity

Series 5 Episode 1 of 6

DURATION: 1 HOUR

As ghost Alex adjusts to life after death with werewolf Tom and vampire Hal, we meet poisonous pensioner Captain Hatch, behind whose foul exterior lurks an ancient evil.

 

 

 

 







__________________

 

Join DMF here too:

Fan Site | Twitter | Instagram | Facebook | Youtube

 

 

DMF
Status: Offline
Posts: 5400
Date:
Permalink  
 

 

Toby Whithouse talks about the name 'Trinity' in his wonderful intro to the new series :

 

"But in the end we settled on ‘The Trinity’, because this was the first entire series with our new cast. Thanks to the brilliance, enthusiasm and sheer elemental talent of Damien Molony, Kate Bracken and Michael Socha; it was their skill and passion that would stop me rocking and dribbling and draw me out from under my desk to actually write the scripts.

And so this series title belongs to them. The new heroes of Being Human. The new trinity."



read more here

 



__________________

 

Join DMF here too:

Fan Site | Twitter | Instagram | Facebook | Youtube

 

 

Molonian
Status: Offline
Posts: 492
Date:
Permalink  
 
SQUEEEEEE!
But who are those people standing next to Hal on that picture?

__________________

"And Tom is feeding me lots of banana, which Damien hates and Hal also hates"

Mad about Lord Harry
Status: Offline
Posts: 683
Date:
Permalink  
 
What a cast list !!!
aw that little quote from Toby W brought tears to my soppy eyes, they are all talented actors I really love the new lineup :D xxx

__________________

My name is Ciara and I've been on the Kia-Ora!!!! :D

DMF
Status: Offline
Posts: 16398
Date:
Permalink  
 
@Lau either side of Hal in the pic - Lady Catherine (Victoria Ross) and Emil (Jeremy Swift)

@HalGal did you see Toby in the cast list for this episode too? woohoo! we are going to see many familiar faces in series 5, including some of the forumers and BH bloggers! I wonder if any of their scenes will be in this episode?

Yes, Toby's intro to the series and to 'The Trinity' moved me too, 'elemental talent' is spot on for the three of them

I have been waiting for this Sunday for a year. bring. it.on!

__________________

Fan Site | Twitter | Instagram | Facebook | Youtube

 

DMF
Status: Offline
Posts: 16398
Date:
Permalink  
 

Just to let everyone know ahead of tommorrow's Being Human Series 5 premiere, 'The Trinity' is repeat scheduled and includes 1 BBC HD broadast:

BBC Three: Sun 3 Feb 2013 22:00

BBC Three: Mon 4 Feb 2013 00:30

BBC Three: Sat 9 Feb 2013 00:45

BBC HD: Sat 9 Feb 2013 23:30 

BBC Three: Sun 10 Feb 2013 02:55

source

and will of course be availalble on the BBC Three channel on the  [url=http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/]BBC iplayer[/url LIVE and for some time aftewards.

International members, whimsyfox has some info for how you can watch on the iplayer outide the uk, so PM her for the details!



__________________

Fan Site | Twitter | Instagram | Facebook | Youtube

 

DMF
Status: Offline
Posts: 16398
Date:
Permalink  
 

**** Heads up everyone! *****

After the show airs here in the uk tomorrow night, this topic will be our place to discuss it - so there will be spoilers! 



__________________

Fan Site | Twitter | Instagram | Facebook | Youtube

 

DMF
Status: Offline
Posts: 16398
Date:
Permalink  
 

 

 

**** 4 HOURS TO GO!!!! *****

fangswerewolfghost



__________________

Fan Site | Twitter | Instagram | Facebook | Youtube

 

DMF
Status: Offline
Posts: 16398
Date:
Permalink  
 

So....initial thoughts on episode 1?

 

WOW!

despite the trailers and clips, the interview, hints, reviews and reviews we have had, and there have been plent, for episode one and the new series, it was still completely new and surprising to me.

The trinity seem very equal - not are if this is the right word but it's late - in their energy, albeit all very different, and the whole episode had a very new feel to it, still the Being Human we know and love but for me a diffenrt flavour not just related to the new supernatural trio.

For me the beginning was lighter, I LOL'd  few times at what will surely become classic Hal quotes , and the tone darkened as the ep went on. Loved all the Hal flashbacks! lots of new characters were introduced but the storytelling is so seamless that you can feel all the individual threads weaving together in one big tapestry of Being Human awesomeness. 

Oh Hal!

I experienced every emotion in this episode - a couple of standout Hal speeches really got to me!

soundtrack brilliant!

Toby Whithouse cameo ---- awesome and lol!!

Mr Rook---ooooohhh!!!

Hatch----urgghhhhh!

Patsy ------exactly!!!

Lady Catherine-----what a heroine! 

Crumb----lol and quirk!

Hetty ----lol!

 

off for a re-watch on the iplayer:

 

http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/b01qm2zc/Being_Human_Series_5_The_Trinity/



__________________

Fan Site | Twitter | Instagram | Facebook | Youtube

 

Damiac
Status: Offline
Posts: 3581
Date:
Permalink  
 

UJ - I remember you saying that you didn't know whether to save up the series to watch it in one hit...and I did wonder if you watched it. 

I've watched every other series on a Monday when I'm home alone.  But I promised myself that if I didn't read my SFX magazine I would watch the series when it aired on Sun.  And I still haven't read it (although I haven't managed to stay completely spoiler free I think I did OK!), but unless I manage to do away with my family between now and next Sunday I will be watching the rest of the series on a Monday! 

Where do you start?  I laughed, I cried, I gasped, I cringed.........sometimes all at once!

Domino - I agree about the relationship between Tom, Hal and Alex.  It's very complicated, but they all have a dependancy on each other relying in turn on each others strengths. 

The 'home secretary' (hats off to Toby Whitehouse) scene definately brings the implications of 'being human' away from merely the domestic - ie, trying to live like a human and trying to get on with the neighbours - and onto a national level.  I'm up for that, but long may the 'domestic' scenes last......the 'rota' scene was a classic!

Ruby - I loved Alex...and the scene between Alex and Tom was heartwrenching.  By being human standards the 'I want to take off these fucking boots' should've been funny......but it just broke my heart.

RougeSang - Couldn't help but make comparisons between Crumb and Cutler.  Turned in such different ways, for such different reasons, and by such a different version of Hal.  First thoughts.....Cutler saw himself as a potential 'history maker' whereas Crumb wants to 'leave such a bootprint on the world'.  Something to ponder once this series has finished I think.

'Oh Hal' indeed, domino.  With every inflection you can sqeeze into those two words.  Currently unable to comment! But I'm sure I'll get there soon.

I asked this question on the blog...but I'll ask here too.

Can anyone speculate (or does anyone know) as to whether Lady Catherine and Emil died because Hal didn't use his own blood, or would Hal have died too if he had?



-- Edited by fifi on Tuesday 5th of February 2013 12:22:28 PM

__________________

".....he'll be with you while you dream"

Damiac
Status: Offline
Posts: 3581
Date:
Permalink  
 

sangate - just been speculating about the necromancer's spell on the bh blog....

I'd started to draw compairsons between the two trinities.....and whether the spell could be repeated with our current trio.  But you've just opened up a thought that I'd had about the 'essense' of the devil - the black dust - being the souls of vampires. 

Back to square one.......

Domino - was writing this when you posted.  I think abiguity will reign right up til the last episode.  My speculation never reaches a conclusion!



-- Edited by fifi on Monday 4th of February 2013 03:19:39 PM

__________________

".....he'll be with you while you dream"

Fan
Status: Offline
Posts: 39
Date:
Permalink  
 

Yeah I figured it was because he'd been in hiding for 60 years. To me they seem a hands-on organisation, so when someone doesn't show themselves, they won't know about them.

I did wonder why Hal turned Crumb, but from what I saw in Hal at that moment it's as you say, he wasn't thinking straight and felt the guilt from what Alex had just said. Then again, she did mention 'you dragged me into this world' and that's exactly what he did to Crumb. But yeah, in the end I think it was as you say an impulse from what Alex said to him.

Edit: Just rewatching that moment, him being genuinely sorry for showing his fangs and black eyes and chasing after him shows how bad he feels about scaring Crumb and wanting to explain. Maybe his way of saying sorry is not to let him die and he thinks if he'll never taste blood again, he can live away from blood and killing.

I think in the case of Alex, she wanted him to be free, what she would want but knows she can't have as a ghost. She wanted for him what she wanted for herself. But yeah, as she herself said: she's new and they thought Hal fell off the wagon, so for him to chain him to the radiator might have been a decision made by that Hal, in her eyes anyway and therefore not a right decision. Does that make sense?

Haha I always try to make excuses when it comes to irks in reviews XD But your ideas make a lot of sense, so I think the reviewer should read them :D Plus, often fans are more invested in a show than reviewers and know more because they have discussed and looked at characters more than the reviewer will have. So excuses might actually just be more in depth analyses :)



-- Edited by sangate on Monday 4th of February 2013 05:16:03 PM

__________________

Photobucket

Team DaMo
Status: Offline
Posts: 91
Date:
Permalink  
 

 Oh, so much to say about this episode but will keep it brief (for me). Our favourite character went through so many emotions, all of them played out exquisitely by Damien. He really was on top of it last night. Nuanced and subtle and wonderfully ‘different’ in each guise, from Present Hal to Past Hal to Struggling Hal. There were differences between the three and that was brilliantly done.

 

Shall put the rest of these incoherent ramblings under a spoilers tag, just because.

 

Spoiler



__________________
UJ
Damiac
Status: Offline
Posts: 1424
Date:
Permalink  
 
Well, I thoroughly enjoyed that. No kidding, Sherlock!

Hal and Tom (aw!), Alex and Hal (ooh!), Alex and Rook (chills!) and Ian!

I was especially amused by Rook being subject to budget cuts. Alternatively, his department could have been contracted out to a private company. That would have been funny. G4 in charge of monster prison!

And it was nice to hear what a vampire is. So, Hal never actually died, he just has a very slow heartbeat. This explains why they have a working digestive system! It sounds more like a mutation. The term 'undead' is simply so last middle ages.

The flashback: most intriguing. Hal's been alive for 500 years, he's been everywhere, done everything, and that so includes monster/mutant politics with werewolves and wizards!

(Just as I'm typing this, I have Call the Midwife on iplayer, and there's Herrick! Ha!)

I seem to be coping with the notion that I have to wait a week for the next episode. Crazy way to tell a story, but I'm doing alright.

__________________
"Nothing sucks more than that moment during an argument when you realise you're wrong."
Damiac
Status: Offline
Posts: 1232
Date:
Permalink  
 
Wow. Just, wow!

What an amazing opener! So many little hints and new characters! Patsy is like a fangirl that has been brought into the show! I love her!

I really liked it when Hal said "oh yes and then we kill him, I remember that part" haha!! Silly Hal

Oh and did I mention thud

__________________

Sooner or later, we all go back to being the monsters we truly are!

 

Damiac
Status: Offline
Posts: 1346
Date:
Permalink  
 
I'm not sure whether Lady Catherine was the Catherine Kirby was alluding to last year. I'm assuming she died in Hal's arms after that ritual went wrong? he didn't rip out her heart or eat it (being a werewolf with toxic blood then he couldn't have unless the ripping and eating part was a euphemism) but there was some serious chemistry between those two.

I've just rewatched with the volume up. I couldn't watch with the volume too far up last night as my family were in bed so i missed a lot of dialogue.

High points: Bearded Hal and did you see the expression on Damien's face when he had to eat a mouthful of banana, poor soul he looked like he wanted to vomit. I have the same reaction to cucumber and carrots. Also really liked the slightly overlong hair too.

Tom was terrific all the way through even though he didn't really have very much to do, the episode was more Hal and Alex centric. I loved that scene in the kitchen when Alex reads her file and she's mourning that she won't feel love and she just wants to take off her boots. Beautifully and heart wrenchingly played.

The devil summoning ceremony. That was genuinely chilling and while watching it a second time, a thought occurred to me...Yvonne had red eyes in her episode last series... is there a connection? probably just a coincidence but it made me go hmmmm for a moment.

I loved Hal's speech in the insurance office to Crumb and the almost suicide and how the other Tom and Alex stepped in and stopped him.

The humour was great as usual, Patsy made me ROFL when she first claps eyes on Hal, pretty much every Hal/Damien fan ever has done that...did Lord Toby lurk on Twitter before he joined i wonder?

Loved how Alex was with Rook, (I almost didn't recognise Toby clean shaven either!)

Flashbacks...lack of shirt, tango music, flirtation, uniform. *thud*



__________________

~I'm not a man of God~

"...Super Duper..." 

Team DaMo
Status: Offline
Posts: 91
Date:
Permalink  
 

Could’ve been a metaphorical ‘ripping of heart and eating it’ that was spoken of (I’d say that my ex boyfriend and first love truly did that to me). Either that or they’re really unimaginative with character names 

I also liked his slightly longer hair. A bit messy, curly at the ends. I thought he looked amazing in that chair. I know he was meant to look sweaty, dirty and uncomfortable but, ironically, he looked hotter than ever when attempting to look a mess. Bless ‘im, I feel his pain re: bananas. Vile things, they are.

I did like Tom. He’s full of heart isn’t he? I suppose they used to say that about Annie. I wonder if they’re moulding Tom into that role.

I’d imagine they were going for the Diablo stereotype with the red eyes. It was a chilling scene. Loved Hal in this scene. Lord Hal in that particular guise was rather delectable, I must say. He had a sort of sassiness to him. It was typical that he didn’t give his own blood though. I suppose they were going for werewolf nobility as opposed to vampiric self-centredness in that scene. Loved it.

Haha yeah, it is pretty much the first thought when you see Hal isn’t it? When you hear him. It’s that initial “Oh, hello…” Only hers was more full on than that. I loved how he looked confused by it at first but then later there was the slight roll of the eyes as if he’s truly used to that response.




__________________
DMF
Status: Offline
Posts: 16398
Date:
Permalink  
 

After reading an ill informed and factually incorrect review in the telegraph this morning that said:

"Hal was having a bad day. He was hungry, and sad about turning his back on vampiredom" (huh? WRONG did you actually watch the episode? this is an insult to the writers and actors - that is not Hal AT ALL.)

and

"The episode was carried by Hal, with the dashing Molony proving to be BBC Three’s answer to Robert Pattinson." (how very dare you... and to put in an Alex kind of a way: I'm not letting a good man be compared just to protect the f***ing Twilight franchise...)

I feel given to have a go at writing one myself but there is almost too much to say - and when try to encapsulate it in words, it doesn't give justice to the quintessential element that is Being Human.

I also wish reviewers would stop now with the comparing to the past. focus on what is here, trust the writers and the creators vision and just let go into what we know is going to be wall to wall stunning television and an amazing ride.

The new trinity to me feel really evenly balanced, each character with their own engaging aura, all very different and the dynamic works amazingly well. In series 4, Hal was almost the father of the household. the strength of the the characters in the new trio seems to have brought us a new more equal dynamic. Alex is strong and takes no prisoners, forging her own unique space at HH and a couple of her 'speeches' left me very wowed and one, very teary. Tom is less "blunt and simpol" and his down to earth goodness is somehow , thankfully, more valued in the new dynamic. Hal - oh Hal.... just when we thought you could not get more multifaceted or conflicted, you show us many many shades in this one episode. vulnerability, inner strength, humour, lightness, darkness -- and that all pervading almost secrecy and aloneness that brings both paths and the tension of a wonderful thriller.

the comedy - Hal being the straight man, frantic and sincere tied to the chair begging to be spared the horror of the shambles around him - to Tom's hilarious budgie line (omg lol) Hal himself has some epic comedic lines early on "a quick run round with the hoover""you people are animals""this is a two sets of marigold problem" "ohhh smell that alpine freshness".

the tone, it felt lighter to me to begin with, with so many laugh out loud lines and of introduction of qirky characters with epic funny dialogue (Hetty, Crumb, Patsy, the Home Secretary.. ) even when we met Mr Rook again it felt like some of the weight of his mystiqe was lifted and he seemed more like a suited bureaucrat of the bridge between the supernatural and human worlds.But then...oh how the threads interwove and the energy deepened and darkened - Mr Rook's murky depths returning in one grueome scene, Crumb morphing from clownish to menacing, Captain Hatch pervading with his chilling true identity,  Lady Catherine the ulimate sacrifcial heroine..and Hal oh Hal...... always breaking our hearts with our own empathy...from the moment he is out of the chair presented with the most extrme of temptations and the consequences of the choices he makes..the 'relationship' with 'Crumb' gives us a chance to hear more about his own experience of becoming a vampire - learning more about Hal from Hal feels like a privelege,  and we were truly indulged with a number of flashbacks.....  

 we are also given the whole gamut of domestic to almsot apocalyptic, a vampire a werewolf and a ghost sitting around  the table at  HH bickering about rotas, and finding new jobs at a hotel, to the ritual of summoning of the master of the underworld, who just so happens to end up sitting at a table in their new place of employment.

Gah.... so much more to say you see.. words don't do it.



__________________

Fan Site | Twitter | Instagram | Facebook | Youtube

 

Fan
Status: Offline
Posts: 39
Date:
Permalink  
 
Domino! Wow! What an AMAZING write up! I have nothing to add actually, just admiration at your review :D

Also, what an idiot at the Telegraph!!! :O Honestly, can hardly believe what they wrote :S

To me, the episode was carried by Damien and that is really the main thing I took from this episode. I absolutely LOVED that about it. The new trio was fantastic and I completely agree that it seems very balanced. I like Alex (I'm sure the next eps will make me love her more) and my love for Tom only grew.

But yeah Hal. Oh Hal. (reading back I see a lot of you are saying that hihi :D)

And yeah, so I wasn't the only one who thought sweaty, dirty, beardy Hal was really hot? XD Not sure it was what they were going for, but hey XD Also can never have enough Evil!Hal flashbacks. Was talking to a friend who said she wasn't normally a fan of flashbacks, but if they consisted of Evil!Hal all was good XD I couldn't agree more.

fifi, I wondered about that myself! The only lame answer I came up with was: vampires are already dead, so maybe he wouldn't have anyway?

__________________

Photobucket

DMF
Status: Offline
Posts: 16398
Date:
Permalink  
 
How right you are San, Damien has a presence when he is on screen, although I do feel that things are evened up with the new trio - they all have powerful energy and they all had their wow moments in this episode - Hal does steal the show somewhat (and i don't think we find that just because we are Damien fans. rather, the other way around).
thank you for the kind words too.. not a review though i was just rambling without forethought but maybe i could use some of that for a review proper.

Lol, I think it would be safe to say that we are all 'Patsys' when it comes to unkempt Hal (or uniformed Hal, topless Hal, new uniform Hal (oh my giddy thud) ) - "HOT"! But Patsy's character highlights to me that we Damien /Hal fans are so not just about that. It was not Hal's hotness that pulled me in to his character, and kept me engaged, it was/is the depths with which he was/is written and portrayed.

I really enjoy the ambiguity of the answer to the question you are posing fifi.... I am happy to read others speculations but for me i just want to be right inside that ambiguity.






__________________

Fan Site | Twitter | Instagram | Facebook | Youtube

 

Fan
Status: Offline
Posts: 39
Date:
Permalink  
 
Haha I loved the Patsy scene! It was adorable and funny in all its cheesiness XD But you are so right!! Actually, I thought about this yesterday when a friend who isn't a BH fan said Damien looked hot and all I could think was: Yes, but.. but.. but.. HE IS AN AMAZING ACTOR and Hal is adorable! And Evil! But so incredibly layered as a character! And.. and.. and.. I found it funny that my first response was to defend him as an actor and Hal as a character, while I can be shallow as hell myself.

Is it next Sunday/Monday yet?! :D

__________________

Photobucket

Fan
Status: Offline
Posts: 39
Date:
Permalink  
 
fifi wrote:

sangate - just been speculating about the necromancer's spell on the bh blog....

I'd started to draw compairsons between the two trinities.....and whether the spell could be repeated with our current trio.  But you've just opened up a thought that I'd had about the 'essense' of the devil - the black dust - being the souls of vampires. 

Back to square one.......


Ooh see, I hadn't even thought about it that way!! That's so interesting though! And trust me, when it comes to theories: don't listen to me, I'm never right, so you might still be! Ooh that really is a very interesting!



__________________

Photobucket

Team DaMo
Status: Offline
Posts: 91
Date:
Permalink  
 
LOl he was having a bad day and was upset about turning his back on vampiredom. More like he was having a bad day because he was out and about for the first time after a month spent strapped to a chair and still wasn’t entirely stable in his sobriety, compounded with the emotional dump that an angry, bitter Alex had just subjected him to. The reviewer was probably on Angry Birds at the same time as watching the ep and therefore distracted.

As for the Pattinson reference, I’d imagine they thought it would be taken as a compliment.
I’m the same re: writing a review. Too much to say. Too much to play with. Just the vibe itself would take up a paragraph; the balance between darkness and light, moody and passionate and fun and flighty. There was so much in it. So much underlying. So much on the surface and so much beneath it. So many questions, so many set ups. So many answers to things I didn’t even know I was asking.

I just like the new lot better than the old. I don’t know why. They just feel better to me. The structure, the writing, even the flashbacks – they got better and better. I started enjoying the transitional scenes more and more towards the end of the last series. The Hal/Cutler ones were phenomenal but these flashbacks, showing an even older trinity than the 1955 one, were just mouth watering. In them we saw so much. We saw something that goes back years for Hal, a pattern, a way of living. We saw that, even in his ‘bad’ stages he had empathy, maybe even love. We saw that he was clever, that he was cunning, that he moves well. We saw that he was able to put aside differences for a ‘greater good’ even when he was in one of his more unpleasant guises.

We saw a confident, flirtatious Lord Hal and a brave, courageous Lady Catherine, Queen of the Werewolves, as such.

Alex is streetwise whereas Hal is old fashioned and Tom has been sheltered. Whilst Hal has a raw nervy edge to him, very dangerous, very volatile, she is the 21st Century Tomboy whose political incorrectness and tendency to speak her mind make her ‘dangerous’ in another, more light hearted way. Her interactions with Tom (from a woman who is used to being around boys) were charming and thoughtful and allowed him to show that he is indeed ‘a good person’. And her anger, pure and bitter, towards Hal, was as understandable as it was uncalled for because of COURSE she’s going to be angry about being dead, about being murdered, about a man she fancied and only wanted to date drinking her blood. It’s infuriating but it’s…well, it’s human, isn’t it? It’s natural.

And Tom. It’s easy to forget that Tom lost the child he was beginning to see as HIS child (all that talk about ‘taking him on with a kid in tow’) and his sadness at handing over that bib and thinking that his best friend had dishonoured the memory of that baby was just heartbreaking. That, and the idea that he is the way he is to keep his dad alive.

I suppose we look and we see because we have followed and related and fallen in love with these characters. We look for more. We look deeper. We see further because we want to. I suppose these reviewers just see the black and white of it. “It was once that and now it is this. Shock horror, what does this mean?” But really, if they got ‘sad about turning his back on vampiredom’ from that I have no idea what they were watching.

I love that we got a Hal episode because he’s always going to be the main focus of the show. It is just that way. And they gave him a lot to work with. They gave us a lot to chew on. There’s always this hint of sadness with Hal; this resounding image of a man forever left behind because the people he loves die, move on, pass over. Yet, he prevails. He survives. There’s something moving about that really regardless of his past, his good and his bad and his ugly.

He had some good lines this ep. The exchange about ‘taking a man home’ actually had my choking on my Vimto. Never thought I’d hear Hal utter those words. Ever. It took me right back to Kevin and Perry Go Large. Not sure I was loving Hetty though.

I love that the conspiracy goes right up to the top, i.e. the Home Secretary. The idea that these things are covered up from the top of the Government chain is a well versed idea and I do like it. Mr Rook freaked me out though. I don’t know if it’s his icy eyes or something more than that but there’s something decidedly eerie about him. “I really liked that pen.” I think it’s the fact that (as far as I know) he’s human. That a human could do something so brutal yet condemn vampires for doing the same? There’s an air of nastiness in that.
Ah, love it.



__________________
Fan
Status: Offline
Posts: 39
Date:
Permalink  
 
RougeSang, that was also a BRILLIANT review. i'm in awe of everyone's writing and analytical skills here :D So interesting to read :)

I'm with you on Mr Rook. At first I thought I was actually going to like him after finding him creepy last season. But his meeting with the HS made me like him. And then the pen happened and I had to revise my opinion again.
And yeah, it going all the way up. That opens so many interesting possibilities!

I also found Tom heartbreaking this episode. Remembering 'the kid in tow' actually makes me even sadder for him losing Eve now. I hope he will get a happy moment this series.

Same for Alex I guess, but her snarkiness makes you forget the pain she must feel sometimes. I found her responses also very human and very understandable, as painful as they were.

I think what I love the most about the writing for Hal is that we get to see all sorts of sides of him in all sorts of different time periods. The writing for him really is superb! Well not just for him obviously, but for his character in particular.

__________________

Photobucket

Team DaMo
Status: Offline
Posts: 91
Date:
Permalink  
 
I just read a review that had a couple of grumbles and, whilst I’m not going to nitpick on here I can actually see where they’re coming from on some level. One of them was that, if they knew who Hetty was it’s a little bit unrealistic that they don’t know who Hal is. But Hal has been in hiding for almost 6 decades so there is that.

Another was why Hal, knowing the complexities and the harrowing nature of vampire life, did not feel it kinder to simply let Crumb die. But he was stressed out, agitated, had just had a guilt trip from Alex and most likely wasn’t in his right mind. The thought of letting someone else die alone was just too much for him so he acted on (irrational, emotionally charged) impulse. And he was willing to end it and do the ‘right thing’ when he became clearer.

The third was why Alex, a newbie certainly but not stupid, thought it wise to ‘let Crumb go’. Again, emotional response as opposed to logical one. She was cut up by this life, this job, this family she will never again have and he appealed to her weak side. She was on her own. On the spot. Of course, letting a vampire go free isn’t exactly the brainiest thing to do I can understand giving in to a plea when you’re feeling fragile.

So – indeed, whilst I might be ‘making excuses’ as a fan I can see some kind of explanation as to this reviewer’s irks. But then again I might just be making excuses. LOL.


__________________
 
1 2  >  Last»  | Page of 2  sorted by
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.

Chatbox

Please log in to join the chat!












Copyright 2012 - 2022 Damien Molony Forum All Rights Reserved.